The Church/State Problem with Blue Laws

Image courtesy of prohibitionrepeal.com

Blue laws are those annoyingly inconvenient laws that prohibit you from shopping for certain things on Sundays. Recently the county that I live in in SC repealed their blue laws that disallowed the sale of anything other than food and pharmacy related items before 1:30pm on Sundays. So, not only was the sale of alcohol prohibited all day on Sunday, but one could also not purchase clothes, toys, tools, etc.; anything that wasn’t directly food or health-related.

I was elated when this law was overturned here recently, but not just so I would be able to shop for anything I wanted to on a Sunday (though the sale of alcohol is still prohibited on Sunday). Repealing these laws is a step in the right direction as far as the separation of church and state is concerned.

Blue Laws date back to the early 1700s in this country and were originally implemented to uphold religious observances. They were implemented for strictly religious reasons and, in many cases, have been maintained for religious reasons. The problem with this is that they violate the Establishment Clause of the Constitution that states

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion.

Blue Laws unabashedly support the establishment of Christianity. Saturday, which is the Jewish Sabbath, and Friday, which is the Muslim holy day, are not covered by Blue Laws here in America. Thus, maintaining Blue Laws that blatantly push for the establishment of Sunday morning Christian services is clearly unconstitutional. Thankfully, many states have already recognized this and repealed their Blue Laws. Sadly, it took my SC county until 2010 to realize the unconstitutionality of their laws.

That is not the end of the issue, though. For though the Prohibition has apparently ended, it is still upheld in certain areas on certain days. It is closely related to Blue Laws in that the sale of alcohol is still prohibited on Sundays in many places, or before a certain time on Sundays. Maintaining laws of this nature have explicit religious goals. If not, then why are Fridays and Saturdays not chosen (Muslim and Jewish holy days)?

Here are the special requirements for the sale of alcohol in SC (find the alcohol laws in your state by going here):

No off-premise alcohol sales after midnight Saturday until 7 a.m. Monday, except in Aiken, Greenville, Spartanburg, Horry County, Colleton County, Richland County, Charleston County/city and Beaufort County.

So, certain counties have chosen to write their own laws which do allow for the sale of alcohol on Sundays, but the state-wide law forbids it. This is clearly a violation of the separation of church and state.

So, why do I care about this? It certainly isn’t because it’s an inconvenience for me. As long as their are laws that violate the religious freedom of anyone in this country, the religious freedom of us all is violated. Keeping the government from promoting the establishment of any religion and from violating anyone’s right to the free exercise of their religion is a fight worth fighting.

Freedom of religion means freedom of, freedom for, and freedom from religion for ALL; not just me, not just you, but everyone.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “The Church/State Problem with Blue Laws

  1. I marvel at those who would force another to conform to their ideals. Clearly we are all uniquely different and should embrace that uniqueness. The God of my faith says we were each given free will to pursue as we will. The God of my faith says there are irrefutable truths by which one may come to know Him. Some do, some don’t, but all have the opportunity of equality in His sight.

    When people become preoccupied with applying pressure on others (external pressure) they lose sight of the true gift of life, which is growing up to (in a complete sense) an awareness of the force beyond this dimension that caused all physical matter to exist. Through thoughtfulness and introspection, considering all others as equal, perhaps even better than ourselves, we begin to see the awesome order and purpose in all things created.

    So, whether you eat or drink or do not, consider all things to be a life lesson for you, yourself. Not one to lord over another. For how will you know if you yourself are wrong. And if you are, what will be the price of it and who will be capable of paying it. So thread lightly, my children and know there is One who is watching. One who sees all things and is exacting justice for all. As sure as the sunrises in the east and sets in the west. It is coming, but there is still time to approach the throne of tender mercy. Consider it in joyful thanksgiving, the time remaining. Each one will be called to account. Do not be oppressing your brothers…

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s